polish test

Energy One

Mr. Wright

Knows some things
I know there are a bunch of threads on polishes, but here’s another.
I have a big Harley dresser in my shop to get painted, and like most of the other dressers I take apart, the rear wheel is nasty. I guess they think “out of site, out of mind”. This one isn’t the first one I ran into with a bad side wall, that couldn’t be seen with the bags on it.
I was digging thru my cleaning cabinet, looking for something to shine up the aluminum wheels, when the thought hit me that this would be an awesome opportunity to put to the test all the polishes I had on hand. After I scrubbed the wheel down with soap and brush, it was still so bad looking I was thinking I would need to sand it and use a polish compound to bring it back.
This is my ratings, not only for results, but also for ease of use. You can see in the pictures how bad the wheel was, and what the product did.
1. MAAS is a polish that a door to door salesman turn me onto. It is expensive, so I don’t normally use it on other people’s turds. I love this stuff, it will remove the little rust spots out of chrome, and water stains out of aluminum. It works best when applied and removed with a terry cloth, the polished out with a micro fiber rag.
2. Zep 5 star. I started using this for copper and brass, and found it works well on plastic lens. I sprayed some electro- cleaner on my engine to get the oil off, and found out the oil gauge had a plastic lens. Which melted the surface into a white goo. I sanded it out with sand paper, the used the 5 star, and I can read the gauge once again. It also good at taking out the fine scratches in aluminum .
3.California Custom purple metal polish, I ran across this at a truck stop. This is what I normally use when doing other peoples bikes, It’s cheep and works well.
4. Beats-um all, doesn’t. I ran across this at a car show. I watched the guy for a hour before I got sucked in to buying it. It works, but it takes a lot of rubbing. I’ll use it more for an after polish, because it does seem to stick to the aluminum longer.

Hold on there's more.
 

Attachments

Mr. Wright

Knows some things
5. Flitz works on a lot of things, but I don’t like it on aluminum, It doesn’t wipe off well, or clean well. It is great on stainless steel and nickel plated trim on old cars.
6. Mothers Mag and Aluminum. I know your not suppose to talk bad about someone else’s mother, but this is my can of Mothers and it sucks… that’s all I’m going to say about it.
7.Star Glow, I don't know where I got it,all I can say is he must have been a good salesman. It works but take a lot of rubbing.
8. Never dull is a good product, and has many good uses, but cleaning this wheel isn’t one of them.
I know there are other products out there, this is just what I had in my cabinet.
 

Attachments

Brew

Troop Supporter
Wow, you have a lot of products... :D Thanks for the report and illustrations...:2thumbs:
 

Letbigdogintocanada

Active Member
I have used a lotta different products and I find that once I get it to a mirror finish with a rouge stick and a buffer,mothers seems to work the best in keeping up the shine,everyone has their preference tho.
 

C00lHandLuke

Active Member
I have used a lotta different products and I find that once I get it to a mirror finish with a rouge stick and a buffer,mothers seems to work the best in keeping up the shine,everyone has their preference tho.
Forgive me in advance if this is a stupid question, but what is a "rogue stick"??
 

HMAN

I just like my Freedom
Rouge is a polishing compound in stick form. Its used with high speed cloth buffing wheels. Different colors for different grits.
 

Th3InfamousI

Administrator
Staff member
You have the lower grade Mothers Polish. The premier product is the Mothers Billet Polish, it runs about $18-20 at Auto Parts stores, I found it on ebay for $10 shipped :up: That shit works well!
 

Mr. Wright

Knows some things
The Maas cleans the best, and the Zep 5 star has a jewelers rouge in it, and does a good job at getting the light scratches out. But like JR was talking about, if it has heavy scratches I use a buffing wheel. I posted some pic of an oil breather I made last week. If you look at them, they started out real rough, and had to be sanded. I started out with 120 grit paper and worked my way down to 2000 grit. Then 10 minutes on the buffing wheel, I had a mirror finish.
 

Mr. Wright

Knows some things
Just a funny side note. If you look at the first picture, you will see a big copper kettle in the back ground. After setting for a few months, it gets really green and tarnished. I spread ketchup all over it, then wash it about 15 minutes later. And thats how I get it to shine like that.
 

pknowles

RETIRED
Just a funny side note. If you look at the first picture, you will see a big copper kettle in the back ground. After setting for a few months, it gets really green and tarnished. I spread ketchup all over it, then wash it about 15 minutes later. And thats how I get it to shine like that.
Must be the acid in the tomatoes. What year bike was the demo done on?
 

Utopiapga

Active Member
I used to drive truck back in the day and have tried everything under the sun. I used to sand down then buff and hand polish 110 gallon tanks on my trucks that I drove until they shined like chrome. I have also used many different polishes since I started buying my bikes as well and have recently stumbled across a product I bought from LOWES and I have to say it goes on easy and comes off easy and leaves very little scratches in the aluminum. You can find this by the Diamond Plated Tool Boxes for your pick-ups! Only around $10 and I recommend it highly!
 

Attachments

Letbigdogintocanada

Active Member
I used to drive truck back in the day and have tried everything under the sun. I used to sand down then buff and hand polish 110 gallon tanks on my trucks that I drove until they shined like chrome. I have also used many different polishes since I started buying my bikes as well and have recently stumbled across a product I bought from LOWES and I have to say it goes on easy and comes off easy and leaves very little scratches in the aluminum. You can find this by the Diamond Plated Tool Boxes for your pick-ups! Only around $10 and I recommend it highly!
Yeah ,it's good stuff,I have tried it too,lol
 

Mr. Wright

Knows some things
What year bike was the demo done on
?

I don't know what year it is, I just paint them. I know the bike has 69000 miles on it, and has been wrecked twice. But what the hell, if he want to spend the money on a paint job, so be it.
 

C00lHandLuke

Active Member
I buy everything I see. In my cleaning cabinet I have Mothers, Mothers Billet, MeGuiars, Eagle One, Black Magic among other things. One of the ones I've found to work best for me is Adams #1 and #2. I consider it expensive but it works like a charm for me. In comes in a small bottle, about 3 oz, and it cost about $10.00 a bottle. ImageUploadedByTapatalk1370312663.185231.jpg
 

Glenn

Member
I been polishing my bikes for 30 years - White Diamond is my choice - turns black instantly, very little hand working and looks close to chrome. Use to be only in small bike shops - can get it now at autozone. Use 100% cotton baby diapers...you will love the finish!
 
Top