I've used both HID and a number of LED's over the years.
My Original HID with the reflector I had was the best light I ever had on a bike.
Went to LED after that -- Good but not the same.
Tried another HID -- slightly better than the LED I had been using but did not last even a year.
Went back to LED
Went to the Sunpie Daymaker clone -- very good.
After accident light worked but things were rattling around inside so I replaced it with a light like this one
https://www.ebay.com/itm/3328453635...%3D|ampid:PL_CLK|clp:2047675&epid=17024931440
Does pretty good but my night vision isn't what it used to be so I try to avoid any serious night riding anymore.
I personally prefer the 6000K lights (whiter) 8000K is into the blueish tint.