just went thru this as DV can tell you. the first starter they put on leaked bad. they replaced it again, no questions and so far it seems good to go. Is your starter banging hard when the bike is hot? That is also an issue these bikes have. mine did. my new starter is just now doing the same thing again only when hot. When it's cold no problem. I'm thinking of taking it back again but the repair shop is a long way from me so I'm holding out on that a little for right now. I have 15,645 miles on my bike.