I remeber a time not to long ago HD dealers were selling for over MSRP and people still bought.
If that dealer has 2-3 09's he is or soon will be paying terms on and he is willing to bring one in for you for list, I don't think that is to bad of a deal in my opinion.
Seriously, since you are paying cash for a $30k plus bike, what's a little more cheese to get exactly what you want?
To the rest of us current owners, it is hard to bitch about the market value of our bikes when in reality, we are the ones guilty of driving them down when we beat the dealers up on NEW pricing.
Let's stick with getting the great deals from the guy who bought one when maybe he shouldn't have. They are going to get rid of it anyways, might as well get the bargin from them.
My 2 cents.