I have an 05 chopper that did the same thing. I bought it in 2009 and the dealer mechanic told he didn't know why but a lot of them just started like that. So I put up with it for a couple years then decided to fix it. First thing I did was remove all BD wiring and rewire it like the bikes I built in the 70's. No wires in the handle bars only lights and speedo. That didn't help, new batteries didn't help, so with WSW help did the 3 phase 40amp stator and Antigravity battery that change was impressive but didn't fix it. Called S&S they told me I needed new rocker boxes or lifter spacers so I chose lifter spacers that didn't help. Called Curtis he thought the starter might be the problem and sent me a different rebuilt one I put that in. First time I pushed the start button it startled me by how fast it rolled the engine over and started. It's a little scary how easy this bike starts now I can't believe it's the same bike I was almost to the point where I was going to scrap the whole engine and drive train for one that was reliable but I think Curtis solved the problem.