Does the soleniod move as well (the thing above the motor with the green wire going into it)?
DogVet, sorry for not responding sooner been out of the house just got home.
The area on the starter you are speaking of does not move at all. It seems the round chrome armature housing is flexing up and down about an 1/8 of an inch.
I just caught this this morning and have been trying to research this today. Here's what I found. BD service tech at a Big Dog dealer I shall not mention here told me from I was describing was probably where the armature housing and the starter come together there is an o-ring or seal and that what I'm feeling is the compression of the seal. I called another BD dealer and left a message for the service manager (out to lunch) to call me back but have not heard back from him yet. A local Harley Dealer has an 06 BD K-9 on the floor. I went there and put my finger on the same area as mine and no movement at all.
My service manual shows nothing (pics) of the starter. I don't know what brand of starter I have but am trying to find that out now.
If I have a problem I feel I have caught before any problems develope but it doesn't feel like it should move at all to me. Kind of puzzled at this stage.
Thanks for trying to help me out on this one:up: