Thanks bdmridgeback!

I do have the screw, but it comes in from the other side on my bike

Sorry my last shot sucked. Could you take another shot of that area but from the top down?
If it was installed backwards then it should be an easy fix :lol:
I looked in the hole and saw that only the one side was threaded. That's why I was so confused.
Here's a more clear shot for those that were confused :up: